With mascaras I have a few specific requirements..
1. They have to be lengthening, but not too lenghtening as my eyelashes are quite long... so they might end up touching my eyebrows (lol) if it's too lengthening.
2. I want slight volume, at the roots. I have long lashes, but sadly there's not as many as I'd like.
3. NO CLUMPS.
4. No flaking.
This mascara ticked 3/4 of the above mentioned. What I didn't like was that it clumped up my lashes. I tried the zig-zagging method, I tried the simple pulling the wand from the root to the tip but nada. Nothing worked for me.
However, the shape of the wand was quite comfortable due to the dip in the middle. It did manage to coat all my lashes. I would recommend this to girls who naturally have a lot of volume, but want something a bit more.
I don't think I would repurchase this.